Paul Bissonnette has questioned William Nylander’s effort

Paul Bissonnette was asked what has gone wrong with the Toronto Maple Leafs and didn’t spread the blame around.
“Probably the biggest glaring thing up front right now is William Nylander five on five,” Bissonnette said on Spittin’ Chiclets. “His give a f*** meter is very low.”

He went back to it later and withdrew the qualifier.
“He looks a little bit disinterested,” Bissonnette said. “No, no, no, not a little bit. A lot disinterested.”

He also reckoned Nylander has some of the worst five-on-five plus-minus numbers in the league.

Does William Nylander have a no-trade clause?

Nylander has played his entire career in Toronto, from the eighth pick in 2014 through to a contract that now runs until 2032-33 at $11.5 million a season. A full no-movement clause is attached to it, which means nobody at the club can send him anywhere without his signature first.

That clause is why the theory Bissonnette repeated matters.

He credited it to Hockey Illuminati, a content creator in Toronto, whose suggestion is that the club went to Nylander and asked him to waive the clause so they could trade him for a defenseman, and that his play has fallen off since.

The idea is not confined to one creator. A version of it has been circulating in Toronto for a fortnight, and the Toronto Sun reported on November 11 that there is a rumor from inside the organization that general manager John Chayka has begun exploring exactly that trade. The same theory was raised on The Sid Seixeiro Show.

The obstacles are considerable. Beyond the clause itself, Toronto have no cap flexibility, and no club is handing over a proven two-way defenseman for an $11.5 million winger without a much larger deal attached.

Nylander has heard all of it and brought it up himself at a media availability, in answer to a question that was about his form rather than his future.
“For 10 years, people have been saying you’re going to get traded, or for the majority of it. It is what it is,” he said. “I have to try and get the puck more on my stick.”

The numbers behind the criticism are real enough. Nylander managed one goal across the six-game homestand that Toronto lost in its entirety, and was minus-four against Colorado in a game where his only shot attempt missed.

Auston Matthews also scored once in those six games. Both he and Nylander hold no-movement clauses, which is the problem facing Chayka whichever direction he turns.

Toronto are 8-12-2.