A former Leaf says Toronto are wasting Gavin McKenna

Gavin McKenna has more points than any rookie in the NHL. He is also averaging under fourteen minutes a night, has been benched mid-game twice, and spent part of last week playing fewer minutes than a seventh-round pick called up from the minors.

Jay Rosehill, who played 103 games for the Toronto Maple Leafs and now works for Daily Faceoff, put his objection in a single sentence.
“McKenna needs to be playing with higher end players or it just doesn’t make sense,” Rosehill wrote on X.

Gavin McKenna this season:

GamesPointsAverage ice timeRank among NHL rookies
211313:561st in scoring

Why is Jim Hiller limiting Gavin McKenna’s minutes?

Jim Hiller has been asked about this after almost every game since the middle of October, and he keeps landing in the same place.
“We don’t want him to be one or the other. He’s just got to learn what an NHL player does typically,” Hiller said after one of the benchings. “Those players with so much skill, in the end, get a little bit more rope. We all know that, but you still have to find your way as an NHL player.”

The numbers underneath tell a different story. McKenna sat the final twelve minutes against Vancouver in a game Toronto won, having taken three shots, with the club controlling 78.7 percent of the expected goals at five-on-five when he was out there, according to Natural Stat Trick.

The first benching was worse. McKenna played 6:36 against Buffalo on October 15 and watched the final 32 minutes of a one-goal loss. Hiller took responsibility for that one at the time.

Rosehill’s specific complaint is about who McKenna plays with rather than how long. Against Colorado, recent call-up Ryan Tverberg was given second-line minutes alongside John Tavares and William Nylander and logged 15:31, while the first overall pick finished with 13:14 on the third line. Tavares has also replaced him on the top power-play unit.

McKenna himself isn’t complaining about any of it.
“It’s going to be harder to come by puck touches when you’re not playing as much, so for me, trying to be around it and get those touches will be key,” he said, adding that his defensive game has improved and that he trusts the coach.

His minutes have swung wildly. He got 17:22 against New Jersey and 10:38 against Minnesota inside the same week.

Hiller has his own problems. Toronto are 8-12-2 after going winless through a six-game homestand, their worst run at home since 1985.