Gavin McKenna was the first pick of the 2026 NHL Draft. 23 games into his career, he has not taken a single overtime shift, and on Thursday night Jim Hiller was asked to explain why.
The explanation has not convinced many people.
What Hiller said
Toronto led the Los Angeles Kings 3-0 at home, lost 4-3 in a shootout, and dropped an eighth straight game. Asked whether McKenna’s five-on-five play was the reason he sat through the three-on-three, Hiller said it was not.
“Not so much. I don’t really evaluate his five-on-five play into three-on-three,” he said in comments posted by SDPN’s Jesse Blake and transcribed by Maple Leaf Hot Stove. “Three-on-three is just a different game in the NHL.”
He’s watched. We’ve had him up and then called him off. He’ll get out there eventually, but it’s obviously a high-leverage time, and you need somebody who can make a play.
But again, I just want to make sure he’s ready for that. I don’t want to put him in a spot that, if it doesn’t go well, then he doesn’t feel great.
It was the fourth time Toronto has gone to overtime this season; McKenna has not played an overtime shift in any of them.
The question nobody can answer
The difficulty with the explanation is the player it is about. McKenna arrived as the most skilled forward in his draft class, a winger whose arrival was the summer’s biggest story and who put up 51 points in 35 games at Penn State before Toronto took him first overall. Three-on-three overtime rewards skill and space above everything else.
Hiller says overtime needs “somebody who can make a play.” Making plays in open ice is the single thing McKenna was drafted for.
The player picked one spot after him
San Jose took Ivar Stenberg with the second pick, and the Sharks have reached the opposite conclusion about what a rookie can be trusted with.
Stenberg assisted on Macklin Celebrini’s power-play goal in overtime to win a comeback game at Montreal on 20 October, according to NHL.com. On 9 November, he scored the shootout winner against the New York Islanders in the eighth round. He has also been used on San Jose’s first power-play unit, where he leads all NHL rookies in power-play points.
| 2026 first round | Gavin McKenna | Ivar Stenberg |
|---|---|---|
| Draft position | No. 1 | No. 2 |
| Team | Toronto | San Jose |
| Overtime | No shifts in four games | Assisted the winner, 20 October |
| Power play | Three goals | Leads all NHL rookies in points |
Where McKenna’s season stands
Not everyone expected him to fix Toronto on arrival. The rookie has six goals and eight assists in 23 games with a minus-nine rating, and has been playing between ten and fourteen minutes a night over his last four games, after 17:22 against New Jersey on 8 November. He has not been asked publicly about the overtime decision.
Toronto are 8-13-3 and last in the Atlantic Division after their seventh straight home defeat. They have not won at Scotiabank Arena since 22 October, a night that also ended with questions about the goaltending, and they play Columbus on Saturday.
Read more: