Gavin McKenna finished Tuesday’s 6-3 defeat in Chicago with an assist on John Tavares‘ goal and not much else. Jackie Redmond, an analyst for TNT who makes no secret of supporting the Toronto Maple Leafs, had seen enough.
“I’m sorry, but if we can’t get McKenna 15 minutes against the effing Blackhawks, what are we even doing,” Redmond wrote on X.
She then worked through the whole thing.
“Can’t play him when we have a lead. Can’t play him when we’re trailing. Can’t play him in the top six because he turns the puck over too much,” she wrote. “He’s bad at D, so we figure we’re gonna play him on our third line. You know. What most teams consider their checking and shutdown line where offense is considered a bonus. Yeah. Okay. Got it. Lean into his weaknesses. That’s what all the greats do.”
McKenna this season:
| Games | Goals | Points | Average ice time |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22 | 6 | 13 | 13:55 |
Why isn’t Gavin McKenna on the Leafs’ top power play?
McKenna was running Toronto’s first power-play unit until the middle of the month and, by most readings, had been good at it. Then Tavares came back from a lower-body injury, the veteran went straight into the first unit, and the 18-year-old was moved down to the second group.
The results since have not helped anybody’s argument. Toronto’s power play has scored once in ten attempts with Tavares restored to it, and Daily Faceoff’s assessment was that the unit was objectively better with McKenna on it.
That is the part Redmond cannot get past.
“Can’t play him on PP1 even though he was stellar there, because veterans,” she wrote. “Make it make sense. I’m so over it.”
Her sign-off was an acknowledgment of what the post was.
“Will definitely delete this tweet.”
General manager John Chayka sees none of this. Asked about McKenna’s role at practice on Monday, he described the 18-year-old’s usage as right down the fairway and said the development is on track.
Jim Hiller has his own history on the subject. McKenna played 6:36 against Buffalo on October 17 and sat the final 32:54, which Hiller later explained by saying the forward had been out of the rotation so long he had gone too cold to put back on.
McKenna is averaging less ice time than Colton Sissons and Nick Paul. Toronto have lost seven in a row.
Read more: