Michigan State was losing 5-1 at Yost Ice Arena when Sean Barnhill hit Nick Moldenhauer from behind, directly in front of the Michigan bench. What followed produced six ejections, more than 100 penalty minutes, and a rematch tonight that both teams are set to play without three of their players.
What started the Michigan and Michigan State brawl
Barnhill, a Michigan State sophomore defenceman listed at 6-6 and 215 pounds, put Moldenhauer into the boards from behind just after the seven-minute mark of the third period. The location mattered: the Michigan bench was right there.
Spartans captain Patrick Geary ended up tangled with several Wolverines, including goaltender Jack Ivankovic, who left his crease to get involved. Barnhill, Shane Vansaghi and Matthew Lahey came out of the penalty box. Michigan’s Adam Valentini and Aidan Park left their bench. Daily Faceoff reports that after a video review, no other Michigan State players did.
The six players ejected
Three from each side received game disqualifications. For Michigan State: Barnhill, Vansaghi and Lahey. For Michigan: Michael Hage, Nic Sima and Drew Schock.
Geary was given a game misconduct and Michigan captain Garrett Schifsky a ten-minute misconduct, but neither was disqualified. Barnhill’s own total came to 17 penalty minutes: a minor for boarding, a five-minute fighting major and the disqualification.
The punch that was not penalized
The detail likely to decide what happens next did not draw a penalty at all.
Daily Faceoff reports that Michigan’s Jack Nesbitt punched Geary while the Michigan State captain was down on the ice, and writes that Nesbitt somehow went unpenalized. Nesbitt scored the game’s opening goal at 5:47 of the first period and was called for slashing twelve seconds into the third.
Adam Nightingale’s response
Michigan State’s head coach did not use the brawl as cover for a four-goal defeat.
“You got to know what you’re getting in for,” Nightingale said. “You got to make some hard plays, right? And they’re going to be leaning for sure on you.”
He then drew the line himself. “You can’t make that the focus, right? You got to play the right way. If you play the right way, and that’s the great thing about our sport, you’ll get rewarded.”
The NCAA record is 303 penalty minutes
For all the noise, Thursday does not come close to the worst of it.
In November 2013, an Ohio State and Bemidji State women’s game finished with 303 penalty minutes, a figure ESPN reported as a record for men’s and women’s games in either Division I or Division III. Only 16 of those minutes had been handed out before the fight started, which began at the final whistle after Ohio State took exception to Bemidji celebrating on their ice.
Nineteen players were disqualified that night, ten from Ohio State and nine from Bemidji State, and every disqualification carried a one-game suspension. The previous high had been 268 penalty minutes, set by the Maine and Boston University men’s teams in 1994.
Against that, six disqualifications and 126 minutes is a serious night, not a historic one.
This rivalry has done it before
Nor is the fixture itself new to this. In December 2022, the same two teams closed a weekend series with a full line brawl as the final horn sounded, also at Yost, as Sports Illustrated reported at the time. Michigan had just won 2-1.
Michigan State defenceman Nash Nienhuis offered the explanation that covers most of what happens between these schools. “I think there’s a lot of emotion in this rivalry,” he said.
The rematch at Munn Ice Arena
Game two of the series is tonight in East Lansing, at 6 p.m. Central.
All six disqualified players are barred from it, The State News reports. A game disqualification in NCAA hockey carries an automatic one-game suspension, which is why the six are out without anyone having to rule on it. Anything beyond that is a separate decision, and both the Big Ten and the NCAA can still add supplemental discipline on top.
If you want to watch what happens, our guide to how to follow college hockey this season has the channels.
Read more: