A clip of Gavin McKenna is going around, and the verdict arrived before the context did. He pulls out of a puck battle rather than letting Samuel Helenius drive him into the boards, Los Angeles take possession, and he wins the puck back with his stick a moment later. A rookie who has played twenty-three NHL games is being called a coward.
This is an opinion piece. The views expressed are the author’s own.
It is the wrong thing to be angry about. Not because the clip is flattering, but because almost nothing in it is news, and because the genuinely worrying thing about McKenna’s season came out of that same night, from his own coach.
Nobody was promised a power forward
McKenna’s physical game was never a secret and was never sold as a strength.
McKeen’s Hockey, scouting him in January before the draft, graded his physicality and competitiveness at 45 on a scale where 50 is an average NHL player. The report put it plainly: “When it comes to playing physically, McKenna just does not have that element in his game.” It added that he “plays quite soft along the boards” and that “when pressure closes in on him, he can be quick to bail out of plays as well, not looking to engage in a battle.”
That was published in January. Toronto took him first overall in June anyway, because the same report compared his offensive game to Nikita Kucherov and Mitch Marner. Not everyone agreed he was what Toronto needed, but nobody disputed what he was.
The clip is not a revelation. It is a scouting report with a camera on it.
Then look at who he was up against
The second thing the clip leaves out is the other man in it.
| Gavin McKenna | Samuel Helenius | |
|---|---|---|
| Age | 18 | 23 |
| Height | 5-11 (180 cm) | 6-6 (198 cm) |
| Weight | 164 lb (74 kg) | 225 lb (102 kg) |
| NHL games | 23 | 114 |
| Career hits | — | 324 |
Sixty-one pounds and seven inches, per the listed measurements. Helenius has 324 hits and 17 points in his NHL career, and winning that exact battle is the reason he has a job. McKenna has 14 points in 23 games. They are employed to do different things.
The thing actually worth worrying about
In the same game, McKenna did not take a shift in overtime, and Jim Hiller was asked why. His answer was not about effort or courage. It was this: “It’s obviously a high-leverage time, and you need somebody who can make a play.”
Read that again. The complaint from the internet is that McKenna will not win a physical battle, which was never his job. His own coach says he is not yet someone who can make a play, which is the only job he has. One of those is a scouting report everyone already had. The other is the man who watches him every day, saying the skill is not ready either.
Be angry about that if you want to be angry about something. Not about an eighteen-year-old declining to be flattened by a man who weighs 61 pounds more than he does.
Read more: